🔗 Share this article

At least eleven jurisdictions and a pair of regions have complied with a recent directive from the federal government to eliminate references of transgender issues and the presence of trans and non-binary people from a federal sex education initiative, officials stated.

The government set a recent cutoff for removing these references, threatening the withdrawal of substantial government funding. Almost every of the agreeing jurisdictions have Republican-controlled lawmaking bodies and mostly GOP state leaders.

Legal Challenges and Funding Disputes

Sixteen other states and the nation's capital have filed a lawsuit against the administration's demand, claiming it violates legislative power, which created the $75m sexual health initiative, known as the PREP initiative.

All jurisdictions participating in the legal challenge are led by Democratic state executives.

In a late Monday court order, a federal judge prevented the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), which manages Prep, from cutting financial support to the Democratic states if they do not adhere.

“HHS fails to show that the updated requirements are justified, nor does it offer any reasonable explanation, other than pretext, for its decisions,” wrote the judge, a U.S. district judge in the state. “HHS provides no evidence that it made factual findings or took into account the statutory objectives.”

Initiative Aims and Government Scrutiny

Prep seeks to inform teenagers on healthy relationships and how to avoid pregnancy and the spread of STIs.

In April, the Trump administration demanded all jurisdictions obtaining program money to provide a copy of their educational materials to the department and its subsidiary, the Administration for Children and Families, for a health content assessment.

By late summer, the government sent letters to numerous jurisdictions, informing them that, during the evaluation, it had discovered “content in the curricula that fall outside the purview of the program's legal framework.”

Specifically, the administration claimed it had identified evidence of “gender ideology,” a phrase often used by rightwing groups to refer to the notion that gender is a changeable cultural concept and that trans and non-binary people exist.

Specific Examples of Requested Changes

The administration directed Illinois to remove a lesson that said: “Adolescents may express themselves in ways that don’t conform with their assigned gender.”

It instructed North Carolina to eliminate a sentence from a educational module that read: “People of all sexual orientations and gender identities need to know how to prevent pregnancy and STDs.”

Moreover, health instructors in many jurisdictions could no longer be told to “show tolerance and understanding for all participants, irrespective of individual traits, including ethnicity, heritage, faith, economic status, sexual orientation or identity,” based on the notices sent to states.

Government Comments and State Responses

“Oversight is imminent,” declared a federal official, acting assistant secretary of the Administration for Children and Families, in a statement. “Federal funds will not be used to poison the minds of the next generation or promote harmful political doctrines.”

Several states and territories stated they would eliminate the content or had already done so. These consist of eleven specific states, as well as the two territories.

Another pair of jurisdictions, Alabama and South Dakota, said their educational programs never included the terminology mentioned in the government's notices.

Effects on Adolescents and Psychological Well-being

Together, these states are home to over 120k transgender individuals between the ages of 13 and 17, according to estimates from a university department.

“When the aim is to help adolescents and give them a safe space, I’m not sure why we are targeting the at-risk teenagers in the population,” said an advocate, who heads an organization that provides sex education in Tennessee.

“When the government says that there’s something wrong with you and the teachers aren’t allowed to provide information or they have to disclose your identity to family – when you know that that’s not safe – that’s horrible for mental health.”

Nearly half of trans and non-binary youth contemplated self-harm in the past year, based on a recent study from a suicide-prevention group. School support for these adolescents is associated with reduced numbers of attempted suicide, the group found.

Previous Actions and Ongoing Disputes

Previously, the federal government instructed a state to cut mentions to transgender topics from its Prep curriculum.

When the jurisdiction refused, the administration withdrew its Prep grant, cutting about $12 million in government money and halting health initiatives in schools, youth centers and group homes for foster children.

The state agency is challenging the termination. So far, it has been unsuccessful in make up for the lost funding.

The government has also told instructors who obtain funding from additional national programs, the $50 million Sexual Risk Avoidance Education (SRAE) and the $101 million TPPP initiative, that they cannot teach about “gender-related concepts.”

An early October court order prevented the administration from changing TPPP, while the latest ruling stops it from changing SRAE in the suing jurisdictions that challenged the initiative.

The ACF office did not provide a prompt reply to a inquiry.